Skip to content
Setting Boundaries in Relationships: What It Actually Means - Health and wellness article

Setting Boundaries in Relationships: What It Actually Means

"Set boundaries" is popular advice that often gets applied as a synonym for cutting people off. Here is what boundary-setting actually involves, and what the research on it supports.


“Set boundaries” has become one of the most repeated pieces of relationship advice on social media, often delivered with a confidence that outpaces the explanation. In practice, the term gets stretched to cover everything from a calm, specific request to a full estrangement, which makes it harder to actually use as a skill. The clinical and communication research behind boundary-setting describes something more precise, and considerably more workable, than the internet-shorthand version.

What a boundary actually is

There is no single research definition of a “boundary,” but a framing widely used by therapists — drawing on assertiveness training and skills-based approaches such as the interpersonal effectiveness module of Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) — describes it as a limit you set on your own behavior in response to something, communicated clearly, and enforced through your own actions rather than requiring the other person to change.

That last part is the piece most often missed in popular framing. A genuine boundary does not depend on someone else’s cooperation to work. “I need you to stop calling me names” is a request, and a reasonable one, but its success depends on the other person choosing to comply. “If this conversation includes name-calling, I’m going to end the call” is a boundary — it describes your own action, and you can carry it out regardless of whether the other person agrees with or even hears the reasoning behind it.

Why the “cutting someone off” version misrepresents the skill

Popular content often frames boundary-setting as inherently confrontational or as a euphemism for ending a relationship. This is a narrower and more extreme picture than what the underlying communication research actually describes. Boundaries exist on a wide spectrum of everyday specificity:

  • Declining to discuss a particular topic (“I’m not going to talk about my weight at dinner”).
  • Limiting contact to certain windows (“I don’t check work messages after 7 p.m.”).
  • Leaving a situation at a predetermined point (“I’ll stay for an hour, then head out”).
  • Ending a relationship — which is a real and sometimes necessary boundary, but represents one end of a spectrum, not the definition of the category.

Treating every boundary as equivalent to a relationship-ending ultimatum makes the skill feel higher-stakes and more confrontational than most everyday boundary-setting actually needs to be, which may be part of why so many people find the advice easy to nod along to and hard to actually practice.

What the assertiveness and communication research actually supports

Assertive communication — a close relative of boundary-setting, involving clearly and respectfully expressing one’s own needs, limits, and feelings without being either passive (not expressing them) or aggressive (expressing them in a way that disregards the other person) — has real research behind it, though how solid that evidence is depends heavily on which outcome you look at. The most consistent finding, replicated across quite different groups (psychiatric inpatients, undergraduates, spouses of people in addiction recovery), is that assertiveness training reliably raises self-reported self-esteem. A 2018 review of the assertiveness-training literature in Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice also found it associated with lower anxiety and depression across decades of studies — while noting that research attention to assertiveness training as its own stand-alone treatment has fallen sharply since the 1990s, largely because it has been absorbed into larger treatment packages (among them DBT) rather than kept and tested as its own intervention (Speed et al., 2018).

Evidence tying assertiveness specifically to relationship satisfaction is thinner and older. A small literature from the late 1970s and 1980s on married couples found unassertiveness associated with lower marital satisfaction and more hostility between partners. A more recent study of 220 adults found no significant direct relationship between assertiveness and relationship satisfaction once self-esteem was accounted for — self-esteem, not assertiveness itself, was the only significant predictor in that analysis (Moss et al., 2023). That is a single small study in a journal not indexed by the major research databases, so it settles nothing on its own; it is worth mentioning only because the literature it sits in is so sparse that no better-powered recent test exists to weigh against it. The honest summary is that assertiveness and relationship satisfaction may well be connected mainly through self-esteem rather than directly — and that nobody has really established it either way.

DBT skills training, which includes an interpersonal effectiveness module covering skills like making requests and saying no, has its clearest trial support — a moderate overall treatment effect in a 2010 meta-analysis — for the full DBT program in clinical populations such as people with borderline personality disorder (Kliem et al., 2010). The interpersonal effectiveness module itself has rarely been tested on its own: a 2015 systematic review of DBT skills training used as a stand-alone treatment (separated from individual therapy) found only preliminary evidence and explicitly noted “little empirical support” for that use, and most available trials test the four skills modules together as a package rather than isolating interpersonal effectiveness (Valentine et al., 2015). Whether its benefits carry over to everyday relationships in the general population has barely been studied at all — one of the only trials to try, a 2023 workshop that taught interpersonal-effectiveness skills to hospital nurses outside any psychiatric context, opened by noting that no prior study had tested this, and found improvements in professional fulfillment and interpersonal coping, though not in every outcome it measured (Wu et al., 2023). Its principles are plausible and widely taught, but that broader extension remains an inference rather than a tested finding.

It is worth being honest that most of the specific research above comes from therapeutic and clinical psychology literature rather than large population studies of “boundary-setting” as a general self-help concept — and even within that clinical literature, the strength of the evidence varies a great deal by outcome, as the gap between the self-esteem findings and the relationship-satisfaction findings above shows. Some of the most viral popular claims about boundaries (that they will automatically transform a relationship, or are a guaranteed antidote to burnout) extend further than the underlying clinical research base was designed to prove.

Why boundaries feel uncomfortable, even reasonable ones

Discomfort when setting a boundary is close to universal and does not, by itself, indicate the boundary is wrong or excessive. A few contributing factors show up repeatedly in the clinical literature on assertiveness and interpersonal skill-building — though, as above, that is a literature on assertiveness broadly, not on “boundaries” as a separately studied category:

  • Learned relational patterns. People raised in environments where their limits were dismissed, punished, or never modeled often have to learn boundary-setting as an explicit skill in adulthood, rather than it coming naturally.
  • Fear of conflict or disappointing others, which is a common and understandable response, particularly in close relationships where the other person’s reaction genuinely matters to you.
  • Simple lack of practice. Assertive communication, like most communication skills, tends to improve with repetition and feels less foreign the more it’s used — this is a skill-acquisition process, not a fixed trait some people simply have and others lack.

A practical starting approach

  • Get specific before the conversation. Vague boundaries (“I need more respect”) are harder to communicate and enforce than specific ones (“I’m not going to continue a conversation once voices are raised”).
  • Separate the boundary (your action) from the request (what you’d prefer the other person do). Both are reasonable to voice, but only the boundary is fully within your control to follow through on.
  • Start with lower-stakes boundaries to build the skill before attempting the hardest ones, similar to how most skills are easier to learn incrementally than by starting with the most difficult case.
  • Expect some discomfort, and let it be present rather than treating it as evidence you’re doing something wrong. Discomfort during a new skill is common and typically decreases somewhat with repetition, even if it never disappears entirely.
  • If boundary-setting consistently triggers disproportionate anxiety, guilt, or conflict in your relationships, particularly if it connects to a pattern from earlier relationships or experiences, a therapist trained in interpersonal effectiveness (such as DBT-informed approaches) can provide more structured, individualized support than general advice can.

The honest takeaway

A boundary, properly defined, is a statement about your own action in response to a situation — not a demand that someone else change, and not inherently a synonym for ending the relationship. The research behind assertive communication and interpersonal-effectiveness skills supports boundary-setting as a genuinely useful relationship tool, but unevenly: the self-esteem benefits are the most consistently replicated finding, while sweeping claims about boundaries transforming relationship satisfaction or curing burnout rest on a thinner, older, and more mixed research base than the popular framing implies. Much of the most specific research on it also comes from clinical and therapeutic settings rather than broad population studies, which is worth keeping in mind against some of the sweeping claims made about it online. Starting small, being specific, and expecting some discomfort as a normal part of learning the skill tends to work better than treating every boundary as a high-stakes confrontation.

References

  • Speed, B. C., Goldstein, B. L., & Goldfried, M. R. (2018). Assertiveness training: A forgotten evidence-based treatment. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 25(1), e12216. DOI
  • Moss, J. G., Mace Firebaugh, C., Frederick, H., Morgan, S. M., & Mozes-Carmel, A. (2023). Assertiveness, self-esteem, and relationship satisfaction. International Journal of Arts and Social Science, 4(2), 235–245. Zenodo — not indexed in PubMed; see the caveat in the text.
  • Kliem, S., Kröger, C., & Kosfelder, J. (2010). Dialectical behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder: A meta-analysis using mixed-effects modeling. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 78(6), 936–951. PubMed
  • Valentine, S. E., Bankoff, S. M., Poulin, R. M., Reidler, E. B., & Pantalone, D. W. (2015). The use of dialectical behavior therapy skills training as stand-alone treatment: A systematic review of the treatment outcome literature. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 71(1), 1–20. PubMed
  • Wu, S.-I., Liu, S.-I., Wu, Y.-J., Huang, L.-L., Liu, T.-J., Kao, K.-L., & Lee, Y.-H. (2023). The efficacy of applying the Interpersonal Effectiveness skills of dialectical behavior therapy into communication skills workshop for clinical nurses. Heliyon, 9(3), e14066. PMC

This article is for general educational purposes and is not a substitute for professional mental health or relationship counseling.

ShareXLinkedIn